HackerTube, but for Everything: Inside the Show HN Clone Wave
On 31 October 2026, HackerTube landed on Hacker News. Show HN spent the next two days filling with copies.
HackerTube, a YouTube-style browser for videos recommended in the comments, was submitted at 19:56 UTC on 31 October 2026. Within about 48 hours, Show HN had at least a dozen cousins: books, Wikipedia, blogs, papers, repos, games, words, Amazon products, an Apple TV app, a TikTok-style feed, a daily playlist, and an index of the indexes. Three more posts were jokes. One was a re-post of HackerTube itself.
Karpathy posted the first one. What followed was a lot of copies, and very little of the traffic. The comment archive is public. Where a builder named a build time, it was about one or two hours, and that time is self-reported.
This was written on 3 November 2026 in Sydney. Times below are UTC, as the sources show them. Sydney is on Australian Eastern Daylight Time, eleven hours ahead. Point and comment totals are a snapshot from about 21:10 UTC on 2 November, which was 08:10 in Sydney on 3 November. They are given as “about” because they will have moved. Counts of videos, books, links, and build times are what the builders posted. Those numbers are self-reported.
What is HackerTube and who made it?
Andrej Karpathy published a blog post dated 31 October 2026 and submitted it the same day under the title “HackerTube: YouTube built from videos recommended by HN.” At the snapshot, that thread stood at about 2,798 points and about 597 comments.
The data counts are his, and they do not all describe the same pool. The submission text says “YouTube-style UI over 6,454 videos sourced from 39,834 HN comments since 2007.” The blog says a model pass narrowed the archive to “40K comments recommending a YouTube video,” then 6,454 videos from 2007 to 2026 across 150 topics. An X post at 18:14 UTC on 1 November says Claude filtered “43M comments over 20 years of HN” down to those 6,454 videos. The 43 million is the whole comment pool. The 39,834, and the blog’s “40K,” are the filtered set that recommended a video. That post showed about 47,080 likes and about 4.30 million impressions at the time of writing. The site was up at hackertube.org.
The blog describes a 50% thumbnail, ForYou recommendations stored in the local browser session, keyboard shortcuts, and a data export. On the thread, murm wrote: “It’s so refreshing browsing this compared to YouTube.”
Then other people shipped the shape with a new last word.
What is HackerBooks, and what other “HackerTube, but for X” sites exist?
The one that travelled was HackerBooks. Rohit Shinde, who posts as roansh, put it on Show HN at 15:58 UTC on 1 November: “HackerBooks – HackerTube, but for books mentioned on HN.” At the snapshot it stood at about 1,793 points and about 298 comments, second only to HackerTube. The post says “~16.5k books that at least two different HN commenters brought up.” The About page, which dates the data 2 November 2026, uses a tighter current count: “15,766 books across 281,363 mentions in 225,861 comments by 57,773 different commenters.” Those figures are the page’s own. The page says mentions were labelled by Claude Sonnet 5.5 as recommend, neutral, or critical, then checked against Opus 5.5 on 400 mentions, with 85% agreement. That agreement is the page’s figure too. It also describes a CSV download, and optional update emails stored in a Cloudflare database. It says the site was built by roansh with Claude Code and inspired by Andrej Karpathy’s HackerTube. He wrote on the thread: “Claude wrote almost all of it, including the data pipeline and the site.” On X the next morning: “Shipped HackerBooks with Claude :) Compiles the HN crowd’s fav books.”
Wikihack (aizk) followed at 05:06 UTC on 2 November, about 327 points and about 100 comments. The post says it scraped “all mentions of wikipedia on hackernews,” with Top, Random, and Rising views, and that “The entire site is served only through the frontend.” It was live at wikihack.netlify.app. aizk wrote: “After seeing Karpathy’s Hackertube and Hackerbooks, I just had to make Wikihack.”
The rest of the real shelf landed the same day. Where a builder gives a count, it is self-reported.
HackerPapers (Wasserpuncher), 07:38 UTC, is titled as 3,314 arXiv papers and the HN conversations behind them. HackerBlogs (mad_eye), 08:16 UTC, is titled “the 9,434 blogs HN people keep sharing.” The post says “about 10.7M links from 518k accounts,” keeps a site when at least 15 different people shared it, offers an OPML export, and says “built it in Orbs with AmpCode.” HackerTube for Apple TV (jnaina), 11:16 UTC, is an open-source tvOS app plus a backend that keeps the data fresh. The repo is public, and the post says you can sideload it with a free Apple ID.
HakTok (droidjj), 13:47 UTC, is “TikTok for Hacker News.” The maker says the work started a few hours before HackerTube, so this one is not only a copy of the weekend. HackerZon (kiliancgn), 16:46 UTC, says “9,532 Amazon products” linked in comments from 2007 to 2026, and “No affiliate links.” HackerWords (streetmeat) went up at 18:13 UTC. HackerGames (Architrixs), 18:49 UTC, says “138 games across 42k+ mentions,” calls the site a work in progress, and adds “(yes, waiting on some tokens as well.)”
Hnrepos.com (richardw), 19:26 UTC, is “HackerTube for Repositories.” The post says he had the domain for a while as a someday-maybe. It names BigQuery on Google Cloud and “Codex as an agent with GPT-6.1 Sol High.” Those tool names are his. He wrote: “figured I had to jump onto the bandwagon! Partly as a challenge to stop navel gazing and ship something.”
Separate from that site, @hotragn posted HackerRepos on X at 14:02 UTC on 2 November. A later post gives self-reported figures: about 440,000 HN comments linking to GitHub, about 95,000 repos recommended at least once, 73% by just one person, and 6,140 that made the cut. He wrote: “Turns out lasting recommendations are rare.” Another post says it “took me an hour to two.” That time is self-reported.
Two earlier posts belong in the count and not in the rush. HackerNewsTV (jimothyhalpert7), at 23:25 UTC on 31 October, is a daily YouTube playlist of the latest HN videos. It stood at about 3 points, and it links an earlier version from 2022. A re-post of Karpathy’s site by paaloeye, at 10:00 UTC on 1 November, stood at about 4 points.
Three posts were jokes. techscruggs linked news.ycombinator.com as “Hacker News – HackerBooks, but for all the posts on HN.” mw888 posted HackerHack, linking the HN homepage, at about 180 points. bambax linked the new-comments page as Hacker News for comments posted on HN.
The idea is older than the weekend. yewenjie posted “Hacker News Aggregators, Aggregated” at 16:40 UTC on 2 November, the site hackeragain.com, and wrote: “Every few months, HN reinvents the same idea.” The site is by Shayon, in Berlin. It lists 22 such projects going back to 2011. It says HackerBooks.com appeared in 2011 and is “one of 11 book collections listed here.” moehm wrote: “Hey, nice, I built roughly the same during the covid era pre AI.” What changed is how fast the copies showed up.
irisflower95 added up HackerBooks mentions by year, a calculation of their own, and got a peak of 22,797 in 2022 and 13,738 in 2025. They asked: “Is this another effect of LLMs?”
How long did HackerTube take to build, and what tools were used?
Karpathy’s blog says the build “takes ~2 hours now,” with Opus 5.5 in Claude Code. The blog says Opus “downloaded all comments of HackerNews”, ran Sonnet over them, and narrowed the set to those “40K comments recommending a YouTube video.” The work he lists as his own was a Google Cloud API key, booting a VPS, and buying the domain. He wrote: “This takes ~2 hours now. I can breathe again.” And: “I don’t actually do anything resembling traditional engineering anymore.” The time, and that split of labour, are self-reported. The model names are his words.
The clones name the same kind of stack, again in the builders’ words. roansh wrote that Claude wrote almost all of HackerBooks, including the data pipeline and the site. The About page names Claude Sonnet 5.5 for the labels and Opus 5.5 for the check on 400 mentions. The HackerBlogs post says “built it in Orbs with AmpCode.” Hnrepos used “Codex as an agent with GPT-6.1 Sol High.” @hotragn’s “hour to two” is the same class of claim. None of these times was checked by anyone else.
A self-reported two hours is the claim behind shipping fast with AI: a first version got cheap, and a copy got cheap with it. Claude Code, Codex, and AmpCode are the names in these posts. Agents, a host, and a domain are already how the tools indie hackers use get described. The raw material is the public comment archive. Each site is a filter on a dataset anyone else can pull. The filter is the product. It is also the part the next person can rerun.
What does “Show HN” mean, and what are the Show HN rules?
Show HN is the prefix on these posts: a project, offered to the thread. The guidelines, read on 3 November 2026, say: “The project should be non-trivial. Don’t post quickly-generated one-offs; anybody can do that now.” They also say: “Please don’t ask friends to upvote or comment.” The page does not date the “anybody can do that now” line. It is the current text. Nothing here shows when it was added.
A Show HN lands in Hacker News as an indie hacking room. That page is plain about the room: it is not a club, and a post can bring harsh traffic or none. Posting into a name people are already watching is a form of building in public. The reach, when it comes, belongs to the trend.
The comments were already tired, and some of them were delighted.
jchook, on 1 November: “Claude speak gives me a gag reflex these days.”
brador: “Every vibe coded software I’m following has stopped updates after about a week.”
sixtyj: “I am a bit tired to bookmark a project that disappears in few weeks.”
thasso, the other way: “I would just love it if the front page were full of "Show HN: HackerFoo" posts for two weeks now.”
jacobobryant: “Coming soon: HackerHackerTube, my website that recommends HackerTube variants posted on HN!”
On the joke, mw888 wrote: “No AI used for this btw.” renyicircle answered: “It’s such a breath of fresh air to see a Show HN that is not AI slop.”
That sameness is the argument in is vibe coding killing indie hacking? A dozen near-copies in two days is one reading of is indie hacking oversaturated? The generic shelf fills. A specific cut of the archive can still be a reason to open one of them. It is not, by itself, a business.
Do copycat launches like these get traffic, and does it last?
Most of them did not, at the snapshot. HackerTube and HackerBooks carried the points. Wikihack was the other breakout, at about 327. HackerHack, a joke, sat at about 180. Most of the rest sat at about 1 to 6 points. Copying the shape was common. Breaking out was not.
tabs_or_spaces wrote, on the naming: “Because if you copy part of a name, generally you’ll never get more popular than the original name.” HackerBooks is the case that still reached second place from a Show HN post. That is the practical form of do you need an audience? Someone else’s front page did the distribution.
Nothing here has published revenue. These are not businesses yet. For how small sites make money, the visible steps are small: HackerBooks stores optional update emails, and HackerZon says it uses no affiliate links. Neither is a sale. Other free launch rooms are getting harder to use in the same week. Reddit’s login wall is the neighbouring change.
Will they last? The comments are sceptical, and the history says the shape comes back. Hacker Again’s 22 entries go back to 2011. moehm said they built roughly the same in the COVID era, pre AI. HackerNewsTV points at a 2022 version. brador’s line about updates stopping after about a week is one person’s observation of projects they follow. It is not a measurement of sites that are only days old.
A short timeline
UTC. Points are the 2 November snapshot.
- 31 Oct 2026. Karpathy’s blog post, dated that day. HN submission at 19:56 UTC. About 2,798 points and about 597 comments.
- 31 Oct, 23:25 UTC. HackerNewsTV. About 3 points. Links a 2022 version.
- 1 Nov, 10:00 UTC. Re-post of HackerTube. About 4 points.
- 1 Nov, 15:58 UTC. HackerBooks. About 1,793 points and about 298 comments.
- 1 Nov, 17:53 UTC. Joke post linking Hacker News itself.
- 1 Nov, 18:14 UTC. Karpathy’s X post. About 47,080 likes and about 4.30 million impressions at the time of writing.
- 2 Nov, 05:06 UTC. Wikihack. About 327 points and about 100 comments.
- 2 Nov, 06:59 to 19:26 UTC. HackerHack (about 180 points), then HackerPapers, HackerBlogs, the Apple TV app, a comments joke, HakTok, HackerRepos on X, Hacker Again, HackerZon, HackerWords, HackerGames, and Hnrepos.
What do you think? Is a named shape on that front page still a way to get a first version seen, or are you already tired of the copies?
FAQ
What is HackerTube and who made it?
Andrej Karpathy published a blog post dated 31 October 2026 and submitted HackerTube to Hacker News the same day, at 19:56 UTC. It is a YouTube-style site of videos recommended in Hacker News comments. His submission text says 6,454 videos sourced from 39,834 comments since 2007. The blog's 40K figure is that filtered recommending set. An X post the next day says a model pass started from 43 million comments over 20 years, which is the whole comment pool, not the recommending set. At the time of writing the thread stood at about 2,798 points and about 597 comments. Point totals here are a snapshot from about 21:10 UTC on 2 November.
What is HackerBooks, and what other "HackerTube, but for X" sites exist?
HackerBooks, by Rohit Shinde (roansh), collects books mentioned on Hacker News. The About page dates its data 2 November 2026 and says 15,766 books. The Show HN text had said about 16,500 books that at least two commenters mentioned. In the same stretch, Show HN also saw Wikihack, HackerPapers, HackerBlogs, a HackerTube Apple TV app, HakTok, HackerZon, HackerWords, HackerGames, Hnrepos, HackerNewsTV, and Hacker Again, an index of older projects. HackerRepos appeared on X, separate from Hnrepos. Three other posts were jokes. That is at least a dozen real projects. Hacker Again lists 22 similar projects going back to 2011, including a HackerBooks.com from that year, so the format is older than this weekend.
What does "Show HN" mean, and what are the Show HN rules?
Show HN is the prefix Hacker News uses when someone posts a project for the thread to try. The guidelines, read on 3 November 2026, say the project should be non-trivial, and say not to post quickly-generated one-offs, because anybody can do that now. They also say not to ask friends to upvote or comment. The guidelines page does not date that line, so it is not treated as new.
How long did HackerTube take to build, and what tools were used?
Karpathy wrote that it takes about two hours now, with Opus 5.5 in Claude Code. He said the work he still did by hand was a Google Cloud API key, booting a VPS, and buying the domain. That time is self-reported. Other builders named Claude, Claude Code, AmpCode, and Codex used as an agent with GPT-6.1 Sol High. On X, @hotragn wrote that HackerRepos took an hour to two, also self-reported. These are the builders' claims about their own builds, not a timed comparison.
Do copycat launches like these get traffic, and does it last?
At a snapshot around 21:10 UTC on 2 November, HackerBooks had about 1,793 points and Wikihack about 327. A joke post, HackerHack, had about 180. Most of the other clones sat at about 1 to 6 points. Commenters doubted that quickly built projects keep shipping, and one wrote that copying part of a name rarely beats the original. The format is older than this weekend: Hacker Again lists examples from 2011, HackerNewsTV links a 2022 version, and one commenter said they built a similar site in the COVID years. None of these new sites has published revenue.